All about Discourses

**FOUND ON GOOGLE**

**FOUND ON GOOGLE**

 

                 In James Paul Gee’s “What is Literacy?” he does talk about both the primary and secondary discourses and how they relate to literacy. But they can be used to talk about life skills we have picked up over the years or have learned. Practically everyone grows up and are taught the basics of what they should know for simple, everyday life; for example, at an extremely young age we are taught to share with others and to do unto others as you want done onto you. This would be a part of our primary discourse; however over time we, as human beings, develop our own understanding of certain material without having to be taught. For instance, we learn how to lie and get away with it which our parents or adults would never teach us because everyone knows lying is bad! Now this brings me to a topic I wrote about before for a previous blog post, the holistic practice of urine drinking. I feel that this topic is important in a sense that it helps educate us about how there are many different people in the world and what we see as the “right thing to do” may not be the same “right thing” to others. And in a way this can be relatable to reading or form of writing because as the saying goes “never judge a book by its cover.”

                The reason I bring up this taboo topic is because I wanted to know whether the ones who practice this certain skill were taught by someone or if they decided to drink their own waste one random day; was it a part of their primary or secondary discourse? Primary would be meaning that someone taught them to drink their own urine for medicinal purposes; so possibly their grandparent or even parents taught them this. This could be quite a lot to think about because it makes me wonder when it all started and for what reasons. I wonder what people who live taboo lives or do many social abnormal things feel about the people who do not practice the same beliefs and or skills they do. On the off side that this remedy does not work, I also wonder why the practitioners still use this type of holistic method till this day. But in order for me to answer these questions, I better do some research or something to help me get a  better understanding of how and whether this practice is a part of a person’s primary or secondary discourse.

                As I have said in the previous paragraph, I have learned that these discourses can not only be applied to literary devices but as well as things we practice every day. Over the semester with all the blogging and reading we have been doing, it really has opened my eyes to not only how taboos are such common things we live among but how some of those taboos are things we eventually taught ourselves over the years without even realizing it.

How are taboos and discourses related?

**FOUND ON GOOGLE**

**FOUND ON GOOGLE**

They’re just everywhere and we don’t even know it. They could be happening right now and we probably don’t even realize it, that’s right—I’m talking about taboos. Taboos happen on a daily basis and we never realize because some taboos that would have not been accepted a few years from now are presently just normal parts of life. Now that the topic of taboos has been touched about, I want to transition into the article that I will relate my subject of taboos to. The article is “what is literacy” by James Paul Gee and in this article it talks about two different discourses; primary and secondary. Primary being the things that we are taught in early stages of our lives; for example, we are taught to share our toys with our siblings or just even share in general. Or we learn to wait patiently for our turn in line. However, the secondary discourse is different because secondary is not what we are taught. It consists more of what we teach ourselves or do because we see others do it. So, it is technically not directly taught to us. For example, we learn how to lie because we want to get out or stay out of trouble. Other times we learn to lie because maybe one of our older siblings or someone we look up to don’t exactly tell the truth when an adult is asking them about something, therefore we think that is it right to lie because the older ones who we look up to are doing it. 

                With that said, the topic of primary and secondary discourses relate to taboos because within the realm of taboos there can be primary and secondary discourses. But these discourses regarding taboos would not be exactly like the ones explained in the article. They are similar but not exactly clones of each other. So the primary discourse may be taboos that are not so serious, like say that someone is wearing really tight pants. There will be people who glance and whisper about their choice of attire but it is such a small issue that I doubt anyone will go up to the person wearing the taboo clothing and insult them because of it. Secondary discourse may be extreme taboos, such as cannibalism. In some countries, cannibalism is widely accepted or at least used to be accepted and no one thought twice about eating other people. Whereas in the United States, for example, cannibalism is a taboo and there are hardly any cases of that subject because that sort of action does not happen often.

                The article “what is literacy” talks of these discourses, but why? Well I would say that the author is trying to open our eyes to how we take part of a primary and secondary discourse and we don’t even realize it. Also because the author wants to make it clear that the things that we do are separated into discourses and open our eyes to the things that are not so obvious. This article is useful in understanding writing because literacy has primary and secondary discourses too. What we are taught in our primary discourse is our alphabet and basic sentences like “Hello, my name is….” Or it could just be everything we have been taught by teachers in school. A secondary discourse could be what we adapted, we learn much of our vocabulary through communicating and even watching television every now and then. There is really no intention of being taught in these situations sometimes but we eventually pick up information along the way and develop our own understanding of how things work.

                I agree with what the author, James Paul Gee, has to say about discourses and the fact that there are two levels. I just never really thought of breaking down what we are taught and what we teach ourselves into two different sections.  This article contributes to my thinking of my chosen topic, taboos, because it has opened my mind to a larger understanding. There are taboos that our parents or adults have unintentionally taught us or taboos that we feel are right at the moment but later in time when we reflect back, we realize that it was not as great as we thought it was. I never would have thought of taboos in the sense of being in different discourses because before I even read this article I had no idea what on earth a discourse even really was.

what the heck is rhetoric…?

**FOUND ON GOOGLE**

**FOUND ON GOOGLE**

To be honest, I still really don’t know what the heck rhetoric is. I mean I know what a rhetorical question is, but if you asked me to define rhetoric or give an example of it then I would just be so oblivious.  From online sources, a rhetoric is a form of writing that persuades or informs people about a certain topic. But, in this case since we are talking about blogs—I guess it would be different. So, since I don’t really know what I’m writing about I’m going to base this blog off of the rhetoric blog analysis paper we received in class. Many blogs about taboos and or social norms usually start from experience—for example, some people write about their pregnancies and birth defects their child suffers from.  Most of the time this topic is not discussed in public or openly, it would not be surprising if people didn’t want to talk about this subject at all. Which is why this topic is seem as such a taboo, it is so significant and can even traumatize an individual.  Another example of how taboo blogs are usually started are for a form of entertainment. Many people write blogs about random subjects to share their opinions and or for others to read to help them pass the time. They could possibly be writing their blogs for a class assignment as well!

The author of these blogs usually have different intention’s, if a blog were about miscarriage the reason they would be writing the blog would be to teach others of their experience and to express how heartbreaking it was. The reason random taboo blogs are made are most likely because they want to teach others of these taboos and possibly persuade them to thinking that the taboo is silly or ridiculous. They may also attack or defend the taboo if they are for or against it. 

Blogs are open to the public, therefore there may be no actual intended audience for random taboo blogs. However, if the blog were focused on a specific topic then it would be intentionally for people who have experienced a certain series of events or just share the same interests in that topic and want to learn more about it.

I’m not too proud of this week’s blog entry, it was more of a topic I was forced to write about. I was not too excited to write about it, it’s a bit confusing to me!

Taboos, Taboos Everywhere

**FOUND ON GOOGLE**

**FOUND ON GOOGLE**

Surprisingly, there is a generous amount of people who blog about taboos. However, there are many different ways to blog about taboos. I, for one, like to create a little intro to work into the topic. Then I talk about the topic itself, and the information I found on it. Then I talk about my opinions and feelings about the taboo. I thought everyone wrote in this style but I was so wrong.

One blogger I found writes about taboos in the style of a poem. Which I thought was extremely creative and interesting because although the blog is really short, it makes the reader think and realize that great things can also be simple. The blog talks about “forbidden love” and how sometimes some relationships have to be hidden because they are just not accepted. Maybe like having a mistress or friends with benefits. To top off the simple poem, the blogger used a giant eye-catching picture. I felt as if I could just sit there for several minutes and just stare into the beauty of the photo that accompanied the blog. This was, by far, one of the best and my most favorite ways to blog about a taboo.

Another strategy to blog about taboos is to pick an odd topic and bring up the history and studies that have been about this topic. Another blogger wrote about a “menstrual cup” and how its suppose to help with periods and catch everything the flows out. The also use studies and incorporate questions that people would most likely have about this topic. For example, one of the questions was “is this cup reliable” and another was “would I be happier if I made the switch from using pads or tampons to a menstrual cup?”  I felt this type of blog is very informational and I felt that I learn a bit or two from these blogs. Although I am not too crazy about these types of blogs, I do not have anything against them. It just is not the type of creativity I admire.

The third type of blog I found was more on the personal side. The blogger wrote about being a stay at home mom and whether that should be considered a taboo. She wrote about what people have said to her about her life choice and their opinions are it. Then she works in her own thoughts and feelings about the career she has chosen, which is an element I like about this blog. To be honest, I would not want to be a stay at home mom because I do not want to have to depend on others—I want the power to be independent. I preferably would not like to depend on my husband for everything because I am just not that type of person.

Even though all these blogs talk about taboos, they are very unique in their own ways. They bring forth different qualities to the taboo blogger table. Although I do like all these different styles, I would much rather stick with the format I have been using ever since I started blogging not too long ago.

YOU DRINK WHAT?!

**FOUND ON GOOGLE**

**FOUND ON GOOGLE**

At first when I found out what the criteria was for this blog I started to freak out. I kept thinking about it and was hoping it would come to me, and it did! I remembered what I said in a previous blog which was “there are a lot of taboos and they can be practically anything, we just never really acknowledged them”, or something like that. I finally thought of something that could relate to my topic, it touches the topic of holistic medicine. For many different religions and cultures have used this form of medicinal therapy to not only cure ails but for different remedies as well. This type of therapy is seen to a vast majority of the population as a major taboo because not only is this our bodies waste but just thinking about it makes many cringe. You guessed it, I am talking about Urine Therapy.

Yes, urine therapy has been used for centuries and is probably practiced today. Different types of cultures and religions use this practice for different benefits. For example, the Ancient Romans used urine therapy to help whiten their teeth. Which I thought was weird because urine is yellow, how could it whiten your teeth? Then I remembered that urine is acidic so it is possible to cause whitening, which made sense. Another example that is absurd is that urine therapy has been used as an anti-cancer agent; in which people who practice this believe that it could prevent the spread or even cure cancer! American Cancer Society has said something along the lines of there being no legit proof that this practice can help cancer in any way. I personally think it is weird how there is no proven cure for cancer and yet people practiced or even still practice urine therapy.

There are some religions, cultures, and or locations that forbid the consumption of urine for medicine. In Islam, drinking urine is forbidden and is considered a sin—believe it or not! According to online sources, the Islamic people do not approve of drinking urine because it is “toxic and filthy”.

Although I know that I will never drink urine for any reason because I know that it is not right. In our society it is seen as a major taboo because our body pushes out pee for a reason—because it is waste and not needed in our system. Therefore, many people would question why others put waste back into their bodies which their body is trying to get rid of. I guess in a way I am a little open minded to this type of therapy. No, I would never try it but I do not have anything against people who do it. As long as I am not involved in the process of drinking urine then I am fine with it!

Cyrus Virus

**FOUND ON  GOOGLE**

**FOUND ON GOOGLE**

                  I’m not sure if this would be considered as a “current event” taboo but it has been going on for a while now. It is still going on as of right now—it is about the way a certain person has been acting that has been catching the eye of the media and the general public. It is Miley Cyrus and her new style, many think that she is trying to break free from her once well-known identity—Hannah Montana. Miley Cyrus has been what the media has been talking for the longest time. She went from her popular role on Disney Channel, to being engaged to Australian actor—Liam Hemsworth—then to her present stage which seems a bit rebeliest and probably even taboo to most people. In a majority of pictures, Miley has been spotted with her tongue hanging out like she is trying to lick her chin, in revealing and provocative clothing, and she also is known for twerking.

                About a few weeks ago, Miley Cyrus performed on the VMAs with Robin Thicke. She was dressed in nude colored latex and was twerking on television. That performance had the media and public talking for several days about her. Many people see her career itself as a taboo because of the way she acts, it just is not accepted in this society. A majority of people would even say that she has hit “rock bottom”.

                I neither agree nor disagree with what everyone is saying about Miley. I agree that the way she is standing out is wrong because she is setting a bad example for the girls who used to love her as Hannah Montana. Most of the things she does now seem very sexual, especially the music video to her new song “wrecking ball”. She is shown in the video riding a wrecking ball naked, which is a taboo because…well she’s naked. However, I think that she is doing the right—in a way. Due to the fact that everything she is doing is such a taboo is why she stands out, and it is also why she is what everyone has been talking about for the longest time. She is getting so much attention, but many would argue that she is getting attention for all the wrong reasons—which is understandable, I see why they feel this way. How do you feel about Miley Cyrus? Do the things she does make you feel uncomfortable or do you think she’s just acting like a normal teenager and going through a phase??

 

freak shows to everyday norms

**FOUND ON GOOGLE**

**FOUND ON GOOGLE**

When I first picked my blog topic, I was so confused as to what I would be writing about. I thought it would just be very vague and limited topic to blog about. However, after looking into the topic and seeing how there are others who blog about taboos too it made me excited about blogging. Honestly, blogging about taboos can push you into a tight spot where you are limited to certain things you can write about. However, to make things seem not as boring you would have to incorporate your own opinions and thoughts. Also, by discussing different types of blogs around the world or ones you see on a daily basis or even ones you see on T.V. could make each blog more interesting and unique than the last.

Everyone blogs differently, but generally it is sort of the same concept. Most blogs of taboo talk about the certain taboo or taboos that are being discussed in the post. I’ve seen a blog post where someone just listed taboos from a certain decade, I think it was the 70’s, with bullet points. It was interesting for me to be able to read about what was and was not accepted back then. It also makes me think how people from different decades and or eras would feel if they came back to life and wandered the streets of today. They would be shocked and disgusted by things we think are just average—like seeing girls in jeans rather than skirts and dresses.

I also know of this YouTube channel that shows a lot of taboos around the world. For example, in my previous blog I talked about cannibalism in New Guinea and brass collars in Thailand. I really like watching the videos because not only are they educational they are also interesting. In the comments below the video, there are a variety of remarks from different individuals. Some say how unique it is and others use the words along the line of “freaks”. I personally really enjoy this topic, I know I say this a lot but it’s the truth! I don’t think anyone would have picked this topic if I didn’t.

cannibalism and coiled brass collars

**FOUND ON GOOGLE**

**FOUND ON GOOGLE**

          There are all sorts of taboos and we may think differently of each one we encounter, some are just slightly odd and others are super bizarre. I recently just watched this documentary that talked about people in New Guinea; they would kill women if they thought they were witches because they believed in sorcery and black evils. They also killed them as a form of revenge. I have not even gotten to the taboo; I know we have heard about many people—even people in the U.S.—who killed people  because they thought they were  witches, but have you ever heard of eating the people after they were killed? Yes , long ago in this country the people would roast the witches on the fire like pigs! Again, I have no problem with this but I just find it so weird because here in the United States, we have had a slightly recent case about a man eating another man and everyone just went crazy. People started to freak out and it was just insane! It is weird to think that something that is not welcomed in another country and that others find to be taboo is not a taboo in another country. In New Guinea, the villagers had no problem with talking about how they used to participate in the killings and feasting of other human beings. As of recent, people in certain villages still kill who they think are the witches and sorcerers however, they are no longer eaten. They are not thrown into water[as said in the documentary]—which I am assuming is a nearby lake or river. There was even a case where a woman was taken from another village and they killed/ate her because the same village did the same so they wanted revenge.

**FOUND ON GOOGLE**

**FOUND ON GOOGLE**

          There are also some taboos that are more on the odd side rather than the, I guess you would call it, creepy side. In Thailand, Padaung women would wear these coils of brass metal around their necks and shackles of the same material around their legs. This process would begin at a very young age and after a while they would add more to the collar to continue elongating the neck. In the documentary I watched, the Padaung woman says it is the illusion of the long necks that they want. In reality, the neck itself is not being stretched; the coils are really pushing down their shoulders. As the coil starts to get longer their spine and rib cage are all deformed and collapsed together. To us it may seem weird but this is exactly what these women want because it signifies that they are tribe women. The Pagaung women are now refugees because they were forced out of their homeland because the military seized their country and said they would modernize the people. Therefore they were forced to leave and went to Thailand.

** FOUND ON GOOGLE**

** FOUND ON GOOGLE**

              In this video, they show one of the women getting their collars taken off to be refitted and you could see the happiness and how excited she was to finally be able to see her neck. But in the end she was eager to put her collar back on because it is a part of their tradition. I personally thought she was going to make a run for it because to me this custom sounds painful and almost like torture. It reminds me of ancient China and how young girls would have their feet bound to keep their feet small; therefore being more attractive. It just sounds horrible and so weird! I don’t know how I would be able to live with bound feet or with coils of heavy brass around my neck.  I am really glad I picked this topic because I have learned about the different traditions people practice around the world, even though it may seem strange.

You will be ticketed or fined for wearing revealing clothes….WHAT?!

**FOUND ON GOOGLE**

**FOUND ON GOOGLE**

In my opinion, it seems as if a majority of teens and young adults in the United States have been into this trend for quite so time— wearing tight and somewhat revealing clothing. To us, it is normal to see people walking around in brightly colored and or skin hugging jeans—even crop tops and bandeaus [and yes bandeau tops are just worn like regular shirts] are now a trend we see often daily. Although the older generations, like our parents and grandparents, may not approve of the fashion choices we make many people still wear these articles of clothing regardless of what others say.

However, in different countries it is against the law to wear such provocative clothing.

**FOUND ON GOOGLE**

**FOUND ON GOOGLE**

For example, in Iran they have enforced dress codes that many would break because of the humid weather and to become “westernized”. But, since so many have not been following these laws Iran has launched a “moral security plan” which allows traffic police to write up civilians with “un-Islamic dress code” fines. Even when the weather gets extremely warm, they have to make sure that the lighter clothing people wear is not against the dress code.

**FOUND ON GOOGLE**

**FOUND ON GOOGLE**

To me, this is understandable because they do not want their civilians to “overexpose” themselves in a way. But, I just wonder to what they consider as against the dress code. What do they consider to be too revealing? I’m not sure is there is really a very descriptive dress code or whether they just ticket anyone who is trying something new that they don’t like.

**FOUND ON GOOGLE**

**FOUND ON GOOGLE**

In addition to the tight and revealing clothing law, they have recently [or at least I think recently] added another law to their list which does not allow men to wear necklaces or have “glamorous hairstyles”. If I read properly, I think those styles were outlawed because they worry it might lead to homosexuality [I’m assuming] because in this article thing I read it stated that if men wore necklaces little boys would start to wear pink nail polish. Well I guess that is not exactly homosexuality, probably more like transgender boys— but you know what I generally mean.

Honestly, I think this is slightly absurd but I have nothing against what they’re doing. I mean all the more power to them. But I just think it is weird that something that we see every day here in the states and that we’re just so used to now, is not accepted in other countries.

Red or Pink but not White

**FOUND ON GOOGLE**

**FOUND ON GOOGLE**

I watched her lips move and shape every word perfectly as I sat there patiently and ever so quietly. The story flowed from her lips as smoothly as water flows through the tap. She was telling me of the day she got married as if it happened not too long ago. I’ve seen pictures of her on this very special day, I wish I could’ve been there to witness it but I was not even born yet. She told me that her wedding dress was a soft pink, not white. I was so surprised that she wore pink. I asked “Mom why did you wear a pink dress, isn’t it supposed to be white?” She paused to think, as if trying to think of a reasonable explanation. She told me that she herself did not truly understand why white dresses were not worn, all she could let me know was that only pink and red dresses were worn. White dresses were not common because when people pass away, their skin looks white and almost ghost-like. Therefore they did not wear white because it seemed washed out and deadly, at least that is what she told me.

So since my mother was not too sure about this, I decided to do some research of my own. According to this website I found, back in the 1900s and even later,white dresses were mainly a “western phenomenon” and that it was a Chinese custom for the bride to wear pink/red dresses because it symbolizes good luck and happiness! Chinese men were not allowed to see their bride till they get to the alter if it was an arranged marriage, the woman would wear a finely crafted silk handkerchief over her face until the man takes it off to reveal his beautiful bride at the alter. WEIRD, right?! As I was researching, I also found out that red is forbidden at funerals. Death is always a bad sign in Chinese culture, and during a funeral the only color worn is black. I thought it was quite silly how they believed in things like this. Taboos are can be bizarre, but like I said before; in some cultures they believe that it is a taboo to NOT get married at a young age. And in other places it is a taboo to get married at a very young age. Another thing I noticed about Chinese weddings, they do not have a ceremony like most weddings in America. The Chinese often just invite their family and relatives to a dinner. There also has to be a specific number of dishes served to each table at the wedding; which is nine. Now I am starting to ramble about non-sense, I honestly did not think that I could write a super lengthy story because I’m not really sure how to write a story based on taboos. I was going to write a story about something that really happened to me but, I wanted to save that for the blog where we have to write about our personal experiences with our topic. I guess this blog entry was a story and my own opinion/ research squished into one entry. This can be a sort of pre-view of my next entries when I actually start writing about the topic and I start getting into more detail about everything. Each week is going to be random, I may start with a taboo about a certain culture or something then move onto something I saw the other day, like someone who was doing something or wearing something that others may consider to be a taboo.